Zeen Connect
Kinesiology: why it's important to know which one you're looking for
A kinesiologist and kinesiology with muscle testing are two different things. Read what the difference is and what the evidence says about each.
In Slovenia, the word kinesiology hides two completely different things, and this confusion is the reason for this page. The first is kinesiology as a university-level science of movement, practiced by graduate kinesiologists — experts in exercise, movement programs, and prevention. Another is so-called applied kinesiology, an alternative practice that uses muscle response testing as a tool to identify suspected imbalances. Same term, two completely different starting points and two completely different levels of evidence. Kinesiology means either the science of movement or an alternative practice using muscle testing. On Zeen Connect, check which of them the provider actually offers. A qualified kinesiologist is an expert in movement and exercise. Applied kinesiology is an alternative practice with muscle testing. Before ordering, check which of the two the contractor offers. Kinesiologist as movement expert. This is a profession with a university education. A qualified kinesiologist deals with movement, physical fitness, posture, injury prevention and exercise adapted to the individual. With him, you can expect an assessment of movement skills, testing of strength and mobility, analysis of posture or gait, and then an exercise plan adapted to your condition and goal. He often works with athletes, with people who have completed physiotherapy, with the elderly who want to maintain their independence, and with employees who are burdened by sedentary work. The meeting begins with a questionnaire and measurements, followed by a program that you carry out on your own or under guidance. This field is based on physiology and movement research and is an established profession. If you're looking for help with sitting pain, returning to exercise after an injury, or putting together a meaningful program, this is the address you're looking for. Applied Kinesiology and Muscle Testing. This practice is something else entirely. The practitioner places a hand on your outstretched shoulder or palm and presses, and you resist; conclusions about sensitivities, emotional patterns or needs of the body should be drawn from whether the muscle relaxes. It is often combined with questions or objects that you hold during the test. The meeting lasts from 45 to 60 minutes and is an interesting experience for many people because it is a form of treatment that involves touch and conversation at the same time. Let's be clear about the evidence: research on muscle testing as a diagnostic tool does not support its reliability, and results often do not agree with repeated tests. Therefore, muscle testing is not a diagnostic method and it is not appropriate to use it to determine allergies, deficiencies or diseases. If someone advises you against foods or medicines on this basis, this is not justified. What to ask before ordering. Since the same term covers both things, the only sure question is: what exactly are you doing in the meeting? If the answer is mobility testing, posture assessment and an exercise program, you have a movement specialist in front of you. If the answer is muscle response testing, it is an alternative practice. Neither is an inherently illegitimate offering, but they are different things with different expectations, and disappointments arise precisely because people order one and get the other. Also ask about the education: there is a formal education for a graduate kinesiologist, but for applied kinesiology there are courses of various lengths. If you are interested in movement, you are looking for the first. If you're interested in alternative treatment, look elsewhere — just know what it is and what it isn't, and don't use test results as a substitute for medical diagnosis. Sometimes to the doctor and sometimes to the physiotherapist. A kinesiologist works with those who are fundamentally healthy and want to improve movement, strength or posture. When it comes to acute pain, injury, condition after surgery or pain of unknown origin, the right address is a doctor and then a physiotherapist — only when the condition is clarified and treated, it makes sense to continue with a kinesiologist, who guides you back to regular exercise. These sequences are worth respecting because exercising for undiagnosed pain can make the condition worse. Applied kinesiology does not replace medical treatment in any case, and its results are not a basis for changing the diet in case of suspected allergy or for stopping medication. If you suspect an allergy or intolerance, there is an appropriate medical diagnosis and it is worth ordering.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between a kinesiologist and a physical therapist?
A physiotherapist is a medical professional who treats injuries and conditions after surgery. A kinesiologist deals with movement, exercise and prevention in people who are fundamentally healthy. Often the work follows one another in this order.
Is muscle testing reliable?
Research does not support its reliability as a diagnostic tool, and the results of repeated tests are often inconsistent. It is not suitable for identifying allergies, deficiencies or diseases — there are medical diagnostics for that.
How do I know which kinesiology the provider offers?
Ask directly what is happening in the meeting. Mobility testing and an exercise program means a movement expert; muscle response testing represents an alternative practice. Both exist, but they are not the same.
Can a kinesiologist fix my back pain?
In case of pain, first consult a doctor to clarify the cause. Kinesiology is not a medical treatment and does not treat pain; it often makes sense later when it comes to returning to regular and safe exercise.
Sources and further information
Informational content from the Zeen Connect editorial team; not a substitute for medical advice.
Last updated: